What happens when faith meets doubt? Journey with Rev. Rob McPherson into Caravaggio’s The Incredulity of St. Thomas and the story of Thomas’ powerful encounter with the risen Christ. Discover how Christ’s peace breaks through fear and sends us forth renewed.

John 20:19-29

In this episode of Art and Prayer, Rev. Rob McPherson guides us through a contemplative reflection on Caravaggio’s powerful painting The Incredulity of St. Thomas. This artwork captures a deeply intimate and dramatic moment after Jesus’ resurrection, focusing on the encounter between Jesus and Thomas, who famously doubted the resurrection until he could see and touch Jesus’ wounds. Through scripture and art, Rob invites us to explore themes of doubt, faith, fear, and the personal nature of encountering the risen Christ.

The episode opens by setting the biblical scene from John 20:19-29, where the disciples, locked away out of fear, are surprised by Jesus’ appearance. Thomas, absent at first, expresses a raw and honest skepticism, refusing to believe until he personally sees proof. Rob encourages listeners to place themselves in this scene, reflecting on their own fears, doubts, and moments of hiding or anxiety, recognizing that such feelings are part of the human experience, especially in the face of uncertainty.

As we engage with Caravaggio’s painting, attention is drawn to its dramatic use of light and shadow, focusing intensely on the figures without distracting background. Christ is portrayed as both vulnerable and radiant, inviting Thomas to touch his wounds, symbolizing an invitation to move beyond doubt into faith. Rob invites us to notice the expressions and emotions of Thomas and the other disciples, helping us connect our own fears and anxieties to theirs, and to bring these honestly before God.

Returning to the scripture for a second reading, Rob guides us to listen for God’s personal message. We are invited to imagine Christ entering the locked rooms of our own hearts and lives, offering peace and presence even in our darkest and most doubtful moments. The episode offers space for prayerful reflection on what Christ’s peace means for each of us and how it might equip and send us into the world.

Finally, Rob reflects on the deeply personal nature of faith and doubt, acknowledging that everyone experiences this tension differently. Yet, in all moments of uncertainty, Christ’s peace is available and transformative. The episode closes with a prayer for that peace, encouragement to carry it forward, and an invitation to share this experience with others seeking hope and reassurance.